| DIVISION 1 | D1 | |||||||
| CHAMPIONSHIP WEEKEND | MID-SEASON CLASSIC | SEASON | |||||
| 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1ST | |
| 2023 |  WFK |  New Wave | 3rd- Pirates 4th- Red Sox | WFK |  RED SOX | 3rd- 4th- | RED SOX |
| 2022 | New Wave | RED SOX | 3rd- Train Wreck 4th- Pirates | RED SOX | New Wave | 3rd- Pirates 4th- Power Outage | RED SOX |
| 2021 |  PopATop |  New Wave | 3rd- Pirates 4th- Fan of the Sport |  COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A | New Wave |
| 2020 | PopATop | New Wave | 3rd- Win or Booze 4th- Outcasts | COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A | New Wave |
| 2019 |  Win or Booze |  Guaranteed Eavestroughing | 3rd- Rebels 4th- New Wave |  RAIN | RAIN | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A | Guaranteed Eavestroughing |
| 2018 | Guaranteed Eavestroughing | New Wave Homes | 3rd- Stix & Chix 4th- Game On | Guaranteed Eavestroughing | New Wave Homes | 3rd- Fan of the Sport 4th- Stix & Chix | Guaranteed Eavestroughing |
| 2017 | Guaranteed Eavestroughing | New Wave Homes | 3rd- Fan of the Sport 3rd- Burger King | Guaranteed Eavestroughing | New Wave Homes | 3rd- 4Play 3rd- Crazy Joe's Gym | Guaranteed Eavestroughing |
| 2016 | Guaranteed Eavestroughing | New Wave Homes | 3rd- Mean Street Stingers 4th- 4Play |  Legends |  Benchwarmers | 3rd- Guaranteed Eavestroughing 4th- 4Play | Guaranteed Eavestroughing |
| 2015 | Benchwarmers |  Fire Breathing Rubber Duckies | 3rd- 4Play 4th- Fan of the Sport | Fire Breathing Rubber Duckies |  Mean Street Stingers | 3rd- Benchwarmers 4th- 4Play | Benchwarmers |
| 2014 |  Urine Trouble* | Legends | 3rd- 4Play 4th- N/A |  Mad Ballers |  4Play | 3rd- Legends 4th- Urine Trouble* | Urine Trouble* |
| 2013 | Urine Trouble* | 4Play | 3rd- Down N Dirty 4th- Unknown | 4Play | Legends | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Urine Trouble* |
| 2012 |  DTM Swingers |  MyFM Rock Stars | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  Down 'N Dirty | DTM Swingers | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | DTM Swingers |
| 2011 |  Wendy's Misfits |  Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Wendy's Misfits | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  I'd Hit That! |
| 2010 |  Lil Rascals |  High Hitters | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | High Hitters (Tied) | Lil Rascals (Tied) | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | High Hitters |
| 2009 |  Bennett Signs | High Hitters | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | High Hitters |  Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | High Hitters |
| *Urine Trouble became the Benchwarmers in 2015. | |||||||
| DIVISION 2 | D2 | ||||||||
| CHAMPIONSHIP WEEKEND | MID-SEASON CLASSIC | SEASON | ||||||
| 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1ST | ||
| 2022 |  Dirt & Diamonds |  One Hit Wonders | 3rd- Brokebat Mountaint 4th- Fan of the Sport | A |  Fan of the Sport | One Hit Wonders | 3rd- No Base Like Home 4th- Dirt & Diamonds | Fan of the Sport |
| B |  Rebels |  Downtown Auto Glass SOP | 3rd- Pound Town 4th- Game On | |||||
| 2021 |  Brokebat Mountain | One Hit Wonders | 3rd- Dirt & Diamonds 4th- Bat Attitudes | COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A |  | |
| 2020 |  The Outlaws | Brokebat Mountain | 3rd- Balled & Beautiful 4th- Breaking Balls | COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A | The Outlaws | |
| 2019 |  Game On | One Hit Wonders | 3rd- Breaking Balls 4th- Downtown Auto Glass SOP | RAIN | RAIN | 3rd- Rain 4th- Rain |  Breaking Balls | |
| 2018 |  Big Sticks * Little Mitts |  R-Safety | 3rd- Breaking Balls 4th- Rebels | One Hit Wonders | R-Safety | 3rd- Rebels 4th- Breaking Balls | Rebels | |
| 2017 |  Yard Goats |  Elgin Realty** | 3rd- Rebels 3rd- R-Safety | Yard Goats | Elgin Realty** | 3rd- Rebels 3rd- S.O.S. | Yard Goats | |
| 2016 |  Jayhawks | Fan of the Sport | 3rd- Crazy Joe's Gym 4th- Yard Goats |  Crazy Joe's Gym | Jayhawks | 3rd- Yard Goats 4th- Fan of the Sport |  Burger King | |
| 2015 | Legends |  Al's Pizza | 3rd- Source for Sports 4th- Swingers |  S.O.S. | Jayhawks | 3rd- Al's Pizza 4th- Legends | Al's Pizza | |
| 2014 |  HD Painting* |  CP Contracting | 3rd- No Glove No Love 3rd- Crazy Joe's Gym | Fan of the Sport | HD Painting* | 3rd- CP Contracting 3rd- Crazy Joe's Gym | Fan of the Sport | |
| 2013 |  Team SPN |  Happy Pak | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Fan of the Sport | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Team SPN | |
| 2012 | Urine Trouble | Legends | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | 4Play | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | 4Play | |
| 2011 |  Ball Breakers | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Ball Breakers | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  Eazy Express | |
| 2010 |  Card and Company | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  Stuck on First (Tied) | Down 'N Dirty (Tied) | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Stuck on First | |
| 2009 | Eazy Express | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Eazy Express | |
| *Mean Street Stingers played as HD Painting **Elgin Realty formerly played as Legends | ||||||||
| DIVISION 3 | D3 | ||||||||
| CHAMPIONSHIP WEEKEND | MID-SEASON CLASSIC | SEASON | ||||||
| 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1st | ||
| 2022 |  Abusement Park |  Bat Attitudes | 3rd- Back Alley Brew Crew 4th- Flippin' Bats | A | Abusement Park |  Balled & Beautiful | 3rd- Bat Attitudes 4th- Flippin' Bats | Bat Attitudes |
| B |  Scared Hitless |  Where My Pitches At? | 3rd- Jayhawks 4th- The O's | |||||
| 2021 |  No Base Like Home | Balled & Beautiful | 3rd- Scared Hitless 4th- The Tropics | COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A | No Base Like Home | |
| 2020 | Athletics |  Beer Ballers | 3rd- The O's 4th- Bat Attitudes | COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A | | |
| 2019 |  The O's |  Jayhawks | 3rd- The Leftovers 4th- Scared Hitless | Rain | Rain | 3rd- Rain 4th- Rain |  The Leftovers- West Jayhawks- East | |
| 2018 |  Beards N Babes | Downtown Auto Glass SOP | 3rd- Aftermath 4th- Presstran Hooligans | Beards N Babes | Downtown Auto Glass SOP | 3rd- Aftermath 4th- Presstran Hooligans | Beards N Babes | |
| 2017 | The O's |  Master Batters | 3rd- Roadies 3rd- OG Road House Sinners |  Breaking Balls |  Roadies | 3rd- No Glove No Love 3rd- Downtown Auto Glass SOP | Breaking Balls | |
| 2016 |  S.O.S. | Breaking Balls | 3rd- Power Up 4th- Roadies | Roadies | Breaking Balls | 3rd- Rebels 4th- No Glove No Love |  Rebels | |
| 2015 | Rebels | Master Batters | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  Crazy Joe's Gym | Breaking Balls | 3rd- Chicks and Hicks 4th- Rebels | Master Batters | |
| 2014 | Master Batters | Jayhawks | 3rd- MyFM Roadhouse 4th- Progress Auto |  Al's Pizza |  Brew Jays | 3rd- Master Batters 3rd- Jayhawks | Al's Pizza | |
| 2013 |  Last Night's Mistake |  No Glove No Love | 3rd- Mad Ballers 3rd- Unknown |  Mad Ballers | Last Night's Mistake | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Mad Ballers | |
| 2012 |  Ball Models |  Source for Sports | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Ball Models |  Royal Bloopers | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  Fan of the Sport | |
| 2011 |  Donuts & Cigars |  4Play | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  AJM Contracting | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  Urine Trouble | |
| 2010 |  Not So-Coolz | Donuts & Cigars | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Not So-Coolz (Tied) | Donuts & Cigars (Tied) | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Not So-Coolz | |
| 2009 | Unknown | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  Ball Busters | |
| *Mean Street Stingers played as Last Night's Mistake | ||||||||
| Division 4 | D4 | ||||||||
| CHAMPIONSHIP WEEKEND | MID-SEASON CLASSIC | SEASON | ||||||
| 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1ST | ||
| 2022 |  Mad Hatters |  I'd Hit That | 3rd- B.P. Ballers 4th- Elgin's Backyard Burgers | A |  Hit Squad |  Bucks & Broads | 3rd- Tailgators 4th- B.P. Ballers | Hit Squad |
| B | I'd Hit That | Mad Hatters | 3rd- The Jokers 4th- Limitless Tattoos | |||||
| 2021 |  Insanity |  Railway City Brew Crew | 3rd- Elgin's Backyard Burgers 4th- Jokers | COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A | Abusement Park | |
| 2020 |  Tailgators |  Elgin Backyard Burgers | 3rd- B.P. Ballers 4th- Strikers | COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A |  B.P. Ballers | |
| 2019 |  The Royals |  Bat Intentions | 3rd- Wanna Bats 4th- Roadies | Rain | Rain | 3rd- Rain 4th- Rain | The Royals- West  Road House Sinners- East | |
| 2018 |  The Leftovers |  Manning Cues** | 3rd- OG Road House Sinners 4th- Misfits |  Angry Raccoons | The Leftovers | 3rd- Wanna Bats 4th- Manning Cues** | The Leftovers | |
| 2017 |  Brokebat Mountain |  Progress Auto | 3rd- Wanna Bats 3rd- Misfits | The Royals | Brokebat Mountain | 3rd- Wanna Bats 3rd- Progress Auto | Brokebat Mountain | |
| 2016 | The O's | Beards N Babes | 3rd- CW Auto Spa 4th Downtown Auto Glass SOP |  Chicks N Hicks | The O's | 3rd- CW Auto Spa 4th Downtown Auto Glass SOP | Beards N Babes | |
| 2015 | Downtown Auto Glass SOP |  Wanna Bats | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Downtown Auto Glass SOP |  B&N Delivery* | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Beards N Babes | |
| 2014 | Roadies | B&N Delivery* | 3rd- Wanna Bats 3rd- Power-Up | Roadies |  Power-Up | 3rd- Wanna Bats 3rd- B&N Delivery | Roadies | |
| 2013 | Al's Pizza | Roadies | 3rd- Rebels 3rd- Power-Up | Al's Pizza | Rebels | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Al's Pizza | |
| 2012 | Power-Up | DLC Wanna Bats | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | B&N Delivery* | Al's Pizza | 3rd- Roadies 4th- Unknown | No Glove No Love | |
| 2011 |  Toogood Studios (Tied) | Royal Bloopers (Tied) | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  Upper Deck | Unknown | 3rd- Roadies 4th- Unknown | Upper Deck | |
| 2010 | Ball Breakers | Toogood Studios | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Toogood Studios (Tied) | Ball Breakers (Tied) | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Ball Breakers | |
| 2009 |  Braxton's |  Molly Maid | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Molly Maid | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Molly Maid | |
| *B&N Delivery became CW Auto Spa for the 2016 season **Progress Auto became Manning Cues in 2018 | ||||||||
| DIVISION 5 | D5 | ||||||||
| CHAMPIONSHIP WEEKEND | MID-SEASON CLASS | SEASON | ||||||
| 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1ST | 2ND | 3RD/4TH | 1ST | ||
| 2022 |  Pitches Ain't Hit |  Minimum Wagers | 3rd- Misfits 4th- The Madness | A |  Misfits | Pitches Ain't Hit | 3rd- Diamond Cutters 3rd- Minimum Wagers | Pitches Ain't Hit |
| B |  The Offspring |  The Oddballs | 3rd- Pitch Perfect 4th- Glo-Balls | |||||
| 2021 | Tailgators | Misfits | 3rd- Diamond Cutters 4th- Glo-Balls | COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A | Tailgators | |
| 2020 | I'd Hit That |  Pitch Perfect | 3rd- Glo-balls 4th- Oddballs | COVID-19 | COVID-19 | 3rd- N/A 4th- N/A | I'd Hit That | |
| 2019 | Railway City Brew Crew | Misfits | 3rd- Caught Looking 4th- I'd Hit That | Rain | Rain | 3rd- Rain 4th- Rain |  I'd Hit That | |
| 2018 |  Bat Attitudes | Railway City Brewery* | 3rd- The Royals 4th- Limitless Tattoos | The Royals | Railway City Brewery* | 3rd- Bat Attitudes 4th- Limitless Tattoos | Bat Attitudes | |
| 2017 |  Limitless Tattoos |  St. Thomas Weekly News | 3rd- I'd Hit That 3rd- Bat Attitudes | The Leftovers | St. Thomas Weekly News | 3rd- Silver Springs Thumpers 3rd- Bat Attitudes | The Leftovers | |
| 2016 | Wanna Bats | Nameless Misfits | 3rd- Progress Auto 4th- St. Thomas Weekly News | Progress Auto | Wanna Bats | 3rd- Sparta Clam Diggers 4th- The Leftovers | Nameless Misfits | |
| 2015 | ||||||||
| 2014 | ||||||||
| 2013 | ||||||||
| 2012 | ||||||||
| 2011 |  Giant Tiger |  St. Thomas Energy | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Giant Tiger | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Giant Tiger | |
| 2010 | Upper Deck | Unknown | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Upper Deck (Tied) |  Berdan Paving (Tied) | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown |  Bad Intentions | |
| 2009 | Not So-Coolz | Upper Deck | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Not So-Coolz | Royal Bloopers | 3rd- Unknown 4th- Unknown | Not So-Coolz | |
| *St. Thomas Weekly News became Railway City Brewery in 2018 | ||||||||
